Puppy Linux Discussion Forum

groundwar · Joined: 06 Sep 2007 Posts: 5

To get my Acer 5570z to run boot up, I've had to specify the nopcmcia flag. The system loads up fine and works great, but the sound won't detect and I think it's related to the pcmcia. If I remove that from the boot flags it freezes at loading kernel modules. . .

Suggestions to get around this?

2.17.

Also, the frameraste on video is cheese. I think I'm only getting 8mb of video memory.

zigbert · Joined: 29 Mar 2006 Posts: 5482 Location: Valåmoen, Norway

I got the same problem with my acer 5610Z.
I booted first with parameter 'puppy nopcmcia'. Then I had no sound because nopcmcia skips detection of pci. To fix this I commented out everything about pcmcia in /etc/rc.d/rcmodules (as Dougal suggested). Now I boot normally (without boot parameter), get pci-devices, but no pcmcia.

groundwar · Joined: 06 Sep 2007 Posts: 5

So your problem remains?

It would appear to me that altering rc.modules and specifying the nopcmcia option look like they would do the same thing. In the rc.modules file there is a lot of if statements looking specifically for the nopcmcia flag. So it does the same thing, I think?

Alternatively, rather than autoconfig at boot, can't I just turn it on once the system is started?

zigbert · Joined: 29 Mar 2006 Posts: 5482 Location: Valåmoen, Norway

I do have sound after my edit.

groundwar · Joined: 06 Sep 2007 Posts: 5

I'm booting up fine now without the nopcmcia. Then I do a modprode snd-hda-intel, then run alsaconfig and it recognizes the card, but no sound output.

Thanks for the help!

Cheers mate!

Flash · Posted: Mon 10 Sep 2007, 23:21 Post subject:

groundwar, is your problem fixed or not? Your last post is confusing.

groundwar · Joined: 06 Sep 2007 Posts: 5

Sorry, let me rephrase.

It's booting without the nopcmcia option.

Then I ran modeprobe snd-hda-intel.

Then I ran alsaconfig. The card came up.

But no sound. No errors, just no sound.

WTF?

Flash · Posted: Tue 11 Sep 2007, 10:29 Post subject:

Try running alsamixer from a console. Maybe something is just turned off.

groundwar · Joined: 06 Sep 2007 Posts: 5

Did that already. Cranked everything up. Think it needs a reboot after the fact?

CD Player runs, streaming content, but no sound.

You ran modeprobe snd-hda-intel?

Thanks for your diligence in helping. I appreciated it!

gamfa · Posted: Tue 11 Sep 2007, 13:20 Post subject:

I see a lot of folks having troble with these sound chips including me. I have a new Toshiba laptop that uses the snd-hda-intel driver. I can't get it to work in Vector 5.8. I can't get it to work in Puppy 2.17.1. It does work in Grafpup 2.0. I just haven't been able to figure why one and not the other two.

They are very strange devices.

KF6SNJ

Let me ask the stupidest of questions:

Which plug are your speakers plugged into? I only ask as the modern PCI computer sound card can have anywhere from three to five jacks. I find that whenever I change out my soundcard, I have to be extra careful to note which jack is my audio out, and even then I have made the occassional error. Now if you are using an embedded card, I would suggest making certain you didn't accidentally plug your speakers into the microphone jack. I have done that before as well. I know these may seem like rather silly or even stupid ideas, but given how we are all humans, we can certainly make mistakes.

Based upon what I've seen posted here, that is about all I can think of. Outside of that, I simply have no clue.

pakt · Joined: 04 Jun 2005 Posts: 1089 Location: Sweden

I'm also trying to get sound to work on an Acer 6291 laptop using Puppy 3.00beta. (Note that I haven't gotten sound to work on this machine with *any* version of Puppy).

I commented-out the pcmcia modprobing lines in rc.modules like zigbert wrote. Now I can boot the laptop without using option 'nopcmcia' and the sound modules load. Unfortunately, no sound though. No errors show in xerrs.log even when I play a sound.

Running lspci -v gives:

BarryK · Posted: Wed 19 Sep 2007, 04:48 Post subject:

Rarsa, I looked at that link, and noticed the comment that it fixes sound but the microphone still doesn't work.

My Acer laptop has a ALC883 sound chip, and there are many reports of people just going back to an older version of Ubuntu or whatever. I think sound works with ALSA v1.0.12, after that the developer did something that has broken snd-hda-intel on many chips.

BarryK · Posted: Wed 19 Sep 2007, 04:56 Post subject:

I notice alsa 1.0.15rc1 is released. I'll try it.

BarryK · Posted: Wed 19 Sep 2007, 05:05 Post subject:

Ah, no, now it's 1.0.15rc2, and the changelog has this:
"hda-intel - Improve HD-audio codec probing robustness"
...I'll definitely compile and test it tonight!